We are now all-too familiar with stories of employees being sexually harassed or bullied at work and keeping quiet for several years in order to keep their job, or for fear of being shamed. Worryingly, the issue of being “silenced” is not unique to harassment alone. A study by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) and the Equality and Human Rights Commission shows that around 11% of women have been fired, made redundant or treated so badly they were left with no choice but to leave as a result of being pregnant or giving birth. Over 20% said they had experienced harassment or negative comments related to pregnancy or flexible working.
The government’s response to the issue has been to propose extending the protection against redundancy to six months after returning to work. However, the results of the survey suggest that a change in law is not what’s required to create a fairer playing field for a woman to progress in their career and raise a family at the same time. Similarly to the issue of workplace harassment, the issue at hand relates to culture, something that cannot change by simply providing a dated “click-through” diversity course or changing the law. Bosses know that pregnant women should not be discriminated against. They know that the law protects pregnant women. They know that asking women about their future family planning is not only
Changing the law is not enough
With 50% of respondents describing their pregnancy as having a negative impact on their job security or opportunities and 20% experiencing harassment or negative comments related to their pregnancy, businesses must do more to protect their staff. The results of the report provide clear evidence that the current law is not being enforced effectively, with women being forced to sign non-disclosure agreements. This shows that many employers are neither concerned with the law nor doing the right thing. A woman who reported her personal story anonymously to the BBC said: “I was the breadwinner, I had no legal cover and so was advised to sign a ‘hush agreement’”, stating she “had no choice” but to sign it. Examples included in the BIS report present accounts of women who experienced stress as a result of not being able to work more flexible hours and stay in the same job. One interviewee said the process for applying for more flexibility was very unclear to her.
Similarly to sexual harassment, inequality towards pregnant woman and new mothers is not simply about whether or not someone was fired for being pregnant. Often comments are made that are designed to make people feel uneasy, such as “she’s letting me down again. She’s going for another midwife appointment”. In such a case, the employer isn’t necessarily doing anything that is against the law and the proposed extension to the current law will not change that. This means the only solution is for bosses across all organisations to install a culture whereby family planning is not only acceptable and will not affect an individual’s position in the company, but that when your employee tells you they are expecting, the first word that comes to mind is “congratulations” or “that’s extremely exciting”, rather than thinking about the loss to the company of the employee having a child.
Having better reporting procedures – a good place to start
It is vital that those who are pregnant feel they have a voice should they experience any unfair treatment. Having a public reporting portal whereby staff can report any behaviour they feel is inappropriate or unfair gives a clear message that the welfare and wellbeing of all staff is of utmost importance. VinciWorks’ harassment whistleblowing portal allows staff to anonymously report unacceptable behaviour that they experience themselves or are witness to. For example, if an individual witnesses a colleague being treated unfairly, they can easily report this behaviour. The administrator is then able to track all the reports that come in and decide next steps.
MyStory: Equality and Diversity – using story-based learning to make a difference
Following on from the #MeToo-inspired course MyStory: Harassment and Bullying at Work, VinciWorks’ upcoming course on diversity brings examples of workplace harassment to life. MyStory: Equality and Diversity presents real examples of discrimination at work through hard-hitting stories. In an effort to quash the phenomenon of box-ticking training, the course has three main sections: Experience, Explore and Share, with the “Seek help” function providing the guidance and resources for staff who wish to report inappropriate behavior. You can request more info on the course by completing the form below.