Employment Rights Act

Making the case for better Health and Safety Training: Your questions answered

Our health and safety webinar on 10 November prompted plenty of questions from attendees, many of them about the practical side of running a safety programme. We ran out of time to answer them all during the session, so we’ve picked out the ones that came up most often and answered them below.

The questions cover everything from working within a tight budget to persuading senior management to take health and safety seriously.

If I only have five minutes with my CEO, which statistic or point should I use to make a case for better health and safety training?

According to the Health and Safety Executive, 40.1 million working days were lost to work-related illness and injuries in 2024/25, including 22.1 million days due to stress, depression and anxiety. That’s a powerful business argument. Poor health and safety affects productivity, absence, retention and ultimately profitability. I would encourage CEOs to see health and safety as an investment in business performance, and ask one question: do we know what our biggest workplace risks are, and what are we doing to reduce them?

Does the Crime and Policing Act mean individual directors can now be prosecuted for health and safety failures?

Directors could already be prosecuted under section 37 of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 where an offence involves their consent, connivance or neglect. What changed under the Crime and Policing Act 2026 is the expansion of corporate criminal liability.

Businesses can now be prosecuted for a much wider range of offences committed by senior managers acting within their authority, including health and safety offences. This makes management decisions and accountability increasingly important, although the Act doesn’t create automatic personal liability for directors.

We’re a small organisation with no dedicated health and safety budget. Where do we start?

Start with the basics, many of which cost very little. Identify your main workplace hazards, carry out a proportionate risk assessment, appoint someone competent to oversee health and safety, and make sure employees understand how to report concerns.

If you have five or more employees, your health and safety policy and significant risk assessment findings must be documented. The HSE provides free templates and guidance specifically for small businesses. Focus first on preventing the most serious and foreseeable risks, rather than purchasing expensive compliance systems.

How should HR and health and safety teams work together on tribunal risk under the Employment Rights Act?

HR and health and safety should share information and coordinate their response to issues involving workplace stress, sickness absence, disability, unsafe working conditions and employee complaints. Many incidents have both a health and safety dimension and an employment law dimension, particularly where workers raise concerns and subsequently allege unfair treatment or retaliation.

The Employment Rights Act 2025 has also extended many tribunal claim deadlines from three to six months for matters arising from 1 October 2026. Employers need consistent investigations, properly documented risk assessments and joined-up decisions between HR and safety teams.

How do we stop training becoming a tick-box exercise when staff are already overloaded?

Training fatigue is a genuine problem, and employers should distinguish between training that is legally required, training that is appropriate to the risks, and unnecessary repetition. There is no universal legal requirement to repeat general health and safety training annually.

Use shorter, role-specific learning, realistic scenarios and targeted refreshers when risks or working practices change. Managers should reinforce learning through everyday conversations and supervision. Most importantly, measure whether employees understand risks and behave safely, rather than simply whether they completed another course.

What would the Fair Work Agency expect to see if it inspected us tomorrow?

The Fair Work Agency, launched in April 2026, can investigate employers and request records to establish compliance with employment legislation within its remit. Employers should be able to produce accurate payroll and working-time records, evidence of minimum wage compliance, and appropriate documentation covering employment agency arrangements where relevant.

The Employment Rights Act also requires employers to retain adequate annual leave and holiday pay records for six years, although the Agency’s direct holiday pay enforcement powers are not expected before April 2027. The Agency is not the general health and safety regulator. Its focus is whether employers can demonstrate compliance with the employment rights it enforces and address any identified breaches.

How do we align HSE resource allocation with management’s operational priorities so that hazard perception issues are treated as systemic risks requiring capital investment, rather than isolated human error?

Health and safety should overlap with all departments within an organisation including operations, with management recognising that repeated safety issues are often signs of bigger issues within the organisation rather than cases of human error.

HSE teams should work alongside management to identify where investment would make the biggest difference. This could include replacing outdated equipment, improving workplace conditions or changing workplace practices. By addressing the root cause of workplace safety issues, rather than blaming human error, organisations can protect their employees whilst supporting their wider operational priorities.

What’s the best way to get buy-in from managers who don’t see the value?

Managers who fail to see the value of health and safety training need to understand that it’s essential. It protects employees from injury and harm at work and it helps the employer meet their legal responsibilities.

Under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, employers have a duty to protect their employees by providing safe working conditions, equipment and working practices as well as training and supervision which means that health and safety cannot be seen by anyone, especially management, as optional.

Many organisations spend heavily on surface-level training yet see minimal long-term impact on the shop floor. How can HSE leaders measure true competency and hazard awareness without expensive setups?

Organisations should continue to invest in quality training that is specific to their working environment and the risks that their employees face in their roles. Training needs to be engaging, practical and designed to help employees during their everyday activities.

Success should be measured by how employees act rather than simply how many people attend a course. Competency and hazard awareness can be quantified through simple observations, employee spot checks, reviewing near-miss reports and checking whether safe working practices are being followed. If these are done regularly, health and safety practices are more likely to become embedded into everyday working culture which can improve hazard awareness and competency.

Who is responsible for Training Needs Analysis (TNA) and can we use it to improve training?

Training Needs Analysis (TNA) should be a shared responsibility between management, HR and HSE teams. Managers and supervisors have more of a day-to-day understanding of their employees’ tasks and responsibilities whilst the HSE teams can identify any gaps in knowledge, skills and safety awareness. Working together, these departments can assess what training is needed, which employees need it and how often it needs to be refreshed.

By identifying specific training needs, organisations can provide more relevant, targeted training for employees.

Do workplaces still need hard copies of compliance and statutory checks, or will digital records or live electronic input suffice?

There is generally no requirement for organisations to keep hard copies of compliance and statutory checks. UK legislation typically requires that records are accurate, securely stored, accessible and available for inspection when required. Therefore, organisations can use electronic systems if they prefer, provided they comply with the above requirements.

Listen again to the webinar.

Newsletter

Compliance news in your inbox

New legislation, regulator action and upcoming webinars, written by our compliance team.

By filling in this form you agree to share your information with VinciWorks. We take privacy seriously, click here to read our privacy notice.